Eating as a pseudo-religion

Eating as a pseudo-religion

Prof. Thomas Ellrott from the Georg-August-University in Göttingen spoke at an event of the branch organization Swisscofel about food as a pseudo-religion His thesis: Eating is no longer just the simple intake of calories. Today, food is a lifestyle product that people use to showcase themselves. It's about identity. And to be on the "right side".

Monday, May 23, 2022

Baking a cake for kindergarten has become a minefield for today's parents. Can there still be sugar in there? Can it still contain gluten? The cake should also not contain lactose if possible. And it should be vegan. Professor Thomas Ellrott, head of the Institute of Nutrition Psychology at the Georg-August-University in Göttingen, uses this scenario to describe the difficulties of modern nutrition at the delegate meeting of Swisscofel. The Agricultural Information Service (LID) reported on this. Often, Ellrott says, health and sustainability are cited as the most important motivations for a particular diet. But it's about more.


"Perceived health"

Gluten-free food has experienced a real boom in recent years. According to Ellrott, the sales figures indicate that many people buy gluten-free products that they do not need for health reasons. The number of people diagnosed with gluten intolerance is much lower than the sales figures suggest. Ellrott explains the difference with the concept of "perceived health", which is also known in science as the halo effect. This applies to products that promise health benefits but do not actually deliver them. "When gluten-free is on a product label, many consumers think that it is healthy – strictly speaking, however, it only says that there is no gluten in it," the nutrition psychologist is quoted by the LID as saying.


Eating as a cult

According to Ellrott, "perceived health" does not yet explain today's phenomenon of "staging individualized nutritional styles". Rather, the topic of nutrition is about creating meaning and identity. "There are more and more people who present themselves through the way they eat and who also shape or influence their identity through it," says Thomas Ellrott. In certain circles, nutrition has even received the rank of cult or pseudo-religion: "This means that you present yourself to others through the way you eat – it's about something pseudo-religious," says Ellrott, referring to David Bosshard, former CEO of the Gottlieb Duttweiler Institute. He once said: "Buying at the organic market replaces going to church for parts of society.


"Instagramability"

Ellrott also sees an influence on the increased importance of food in the advent of social media. Pictures of perfectly prepared menus are posted there every day. Food thus becomes a digital status symbol. By presenting their food, people also share their values with the community. According to Ellrott, certain characteristics are associated with the diet. Your own style of nutrition becomes a commitment to the outside, which can develop into a sense of moral superiority.


Reducing complexity

Fixed rules regarding eating behavior also help people to reduce complexity. If you decide to eat vegan or gluten-free, then suddenly many foods are no longer suitable. "This simplifies life – you don't have to make decisions all the time," says Thomas Ellrott. If you succeed in maintaining a path that you have decided on, you will feel self-efficacious. "It's all about the feeling of control," says Ellrott. The control over one's own eating behavior gives the people a good feeling. Health and sustainability are therefore not the only reasons why people choose a particular diet. Equally important aspects, according to the nutritional psychologist, are identity, belonging to a social community, reducing complexity or gaining a sense of control over one's own life.

Related articles

‘Highly processed’ is not a dirty word
Media

‘Highly processed’ is not a dirty word

The media repeatedly warns against ‘highly processed foods’. But are frozen pizzas and the like really that unhealthy? Not at all, according to nutritionist and professor emeritus Hannelore Daniel. Her appeal: stop badmouthing ready-made products across the board.

This insect poses an existential threat to German farmers
Media

This insect poses an existential threat to German farmers

The reed glasswing cicada is spreading rapidly and threatening potatoes, sugar beets and other crops. Its bacterial pathogens cause massive crop losses. Germany is currently particularly affected, but there are also increasing signs of a growing threat in Switzerland.

The opponents of green genetic engineering lack facts. Their anti-attitude is a dangerous ideology
Media

The opponents of green genetic engineering lack facts. Their anti-attitude is a dangerous ideology

Switzerland and the EU will decide on the cultivation of plants modified using new breeding technologies in 2025. Authorisation is sensible – and long overdue. After all, genetic engineering is already widespread.

‘There is no such thing as chemical-free food – there never has been and there never will be’
Media

‘There is no such thing as chemical-free food – there never has been and there never will be’

Chemical residues in our food are a hotly debated topic in the media time and again. A glance at Austria shows that it is an illusion to believe that residue-free food production is possible. This is because residues come from both natural and synthetic sources. And the same applies to all of them: it is the quantity that makes the poison.

More contributions from Media